Unemployment in the UK may be at its lowest since 1975 but the picture certainly doesn’t feel rosy for many businesses. With nearly 100,000 redundancies last year in the UK, it’s likely that many HR professionals and business leaders will be tasked with it at some point in their working lives.
That said, the first and most important step is to ensure you're really in a redundancy situation. Review your finances and check your options before you jump into laying off staff you may need to re-hire in the future.
If you're losing substantial business and revenue, it might be time to scale back.
Voluntary redundancy is offered when employers don’t want to resort to compulsory redundancy. The company will send out a voluntary redundancy letter to all eligible employees asking for volunteers to be made redundant.
If too few people volunteer for redundancy, compulsory redundancy may still be necessary for some people. But the fewer compulsory redundancies made, the lower the number of potential legal claims – not to mention a happier final workforce.
The idea is to make voluntary redundancy more attractive to employees, to avoid the unpleasantness of having to pick and choose individuals to be made compulsorily redundant. A voluntary redundancy usually involves a greater payout than compulsory redundancy. Employees can also negotiate their voluntary redundancy notice period and benefits.
Every employer must follow the proper voluntary redundancy process. The first step is to write a voluntary redundancy letter explaining the situation and asking for members of staff to volunteer.
By being truthful and transparent about the difficulties the company is facing, managers can build trust with their employees and avoid any whispering by the water cooler. It’s a good idea at this point to set up a point of contact for people who have questions.
Employers must also be prepared for staff to ask about the voluntary redundancy pay package and any other incentives you’re offering. Ensure you’ve decided these details in advance so there’s no confusion or loss of trust at this stage.
Employees who volunteer to be made redundant are still legally considered to have been made redundant. They also have the same rights. This means they have a legal right to consultation.
Consultation involves an employer speaking to staff about why they’re being offered voluntary redundancy and any alternatives which may be on the table.
If an employer is making 20 or more employees redundant at the same time, the consultation should take place between the employer and a representative (rep).
If the company is represented by a trade union, this will be a union rep. If not, an employee will be elected as rep.
Collective consultations must cover:
For 20 to 99 redundancies, the consultation must start at least 30 days before any dismissals take effect. If 100 or more people are being made redundant this needs to start at least 45 days in advance.
Of course, even with voluntary redundancies people still need time to find new jobs and retrain if necessary. If an employee has been continuously employed for two years by the end of their notice period, they’re legally allowed a reasonable amount of time off to look for another job. They can also use this time to arrange training or re-skill.
However, no matter how much time an employee takes to look for another job, the employer only has to pay 40% of one week’s pay.
Often, payments for voluntary redundancy are larger sums than statutory redundancy pay. This makes it appear more financially attractive for an employee to agree to terminate their contract. It’s up to the employer whether additional benefits such as pension scheme and private health insurance are continued for the duration of the voluntary redundancy notice period.
In legal terms, managers offering voluntary redundancy only have to provide statutory redundancy pay, and then only if the employees have been working at the company for over two years. However, you’ll need to tread carefully if you want to attract enough volunteers for voluntary redundancy and maintain employee satisfaction.
Here’s a handy table to work out how much statutory redundancy pay is owed.
For example, if you were made redundant on or after 6 April 2018, your weekly pay is capped at £508 and the maximum statutory redundancy pay you can get is £15,240. If you were made redundant before 6 April 2018, these amounts will be lower.
Remember: Redundancy pay (including any severance pay) under £30,000 isn’t taxable.
Check out this statutory redundancy pay calculator to find out exactly how much would be owed.
The obvious disadvantage of voluntary redundancy is that the employees most likely to volunteer for redundancy are often those the employer would least wish to lose, namely the good performers who are able to find a new job pretty easily.
Employers can avoid this by making it clear that not all offers of voluntary redundancy will be accepted, and then refuse applications from employees they wish to keep.
A risky venture
But this idea isn’t without risk. Employees who are compulsorily made redundant later on may complain that their jobs could have been saved if the voluntary redundancy applications had been granted. In short, their dismissals are unfair. Employers need to have clear reasons – supported by records such as appraisals – for keeping employees whose voluntary applications were refused.
Commonly used – and usually fair – selection criteria include skills, experience, performance, disciplinary records and attendance (adjusting for serious illness, family leave and other legitimate reasons).
But it’s not just about trimming the fat. An employee whose application for voluntary redundancy is turned down is likely to feel pretty demotivated, further damaging staff morale.
Employees nearing retirement age might be keen for a little extra cash before they start taking their pension. However, employers should be wary of targeting older employees for voluntary redundancy as this could amount to age discrimination.
Lay-offs tend to increase employees’ levels of stress and decrease morale, job satisfaction, and trust. One survey found that 73% of survivors felt demoralised, 64% felt demotivated, and 74% said they shut down and turned off. In other words, just when a company needs its staff to pull out all the stops, they stop playing altogether.
Such perceptual changes are linked to greater turnover, diminished willingness of employees to help one another, and poorer job and company performance. Not exactly what you had in mind.
Any manager taking on a redundancy situation needs to help employees see the downsizing process as fair and show that every other option had been considered first.
Reassuring measures such as a moratorium on future lay-offs, might also be helpful. One study by Harvard Business Review found that the anticipation of downsizing can have an even stronger negative effect than layoffs themselves on employees’ feelings about their work environment.
Everyone has heard a nasty redundancy story. People fired at a staff meeting, tears over the coffee machine – these stories travel and they can seriously damage a company’s reputation. After all, who would recommend an employer who doesn’t treat their staff with basic respect?
Redundancy doesn’t need to be a terrible thing – in fact it’s an opportunity to show how communicative and respectful you are to your employees. A few compassionate touches can mean the difference between your company preserving its glowing reputation and becoming a byword for nastiness.
When media conglomerate Time Warner laid off employees in its corporate office in 2008, management ensured that the exit booklet contained more than the standard legal info. Instead, it offered options.
Warner’s HR staff searched thousands of job postings within the company to create lists of open positions, customised for each person being let go. If they chose to apply, the departing employees would be offered preferential ‘current employee’ status. These talented people were also flagged up to divisional heads of department to smooth the way to a new position.
In tough times, a company which cares about every employee – even the ones who get fired – creates the kind of loyalty that isn’t forgotten.
Ultimately it’s up to you to decide whether voluntary redundancy is right for you and your company. Whatever your decision, you can make voluntary redundancy a success by communicating well with your employees and being fair and transparent at every stage of the process.
As ever, if you have doubts about the legal implications of your decisions be sure to get legal advice – it’s always better to avoid your name coming up at an employment tribunal.
Have these nuggets of HR gold delivered straight to your inbox once a month. Just pop your email address in below.
Thanks for subscribing